Engineering students' proposals for complex building project on inner city site win All Ireland CIOB Challenge 2019
Charted Institute of Building Challenge (CIOB)’s competition attracted entries from Higher Education colleges across Ireland
Date Article Written:
Tuesday, November 19, 2019
A team of talented building and civil engineering degree students in GMIT have won the coveted All Ireland Chartered Institute of Building (CIOB) Student Challenge 2019 for developing the best detailed proposals for a complex building heritage project on a busy commercial site in inner city Dublin.
The GMIT multi-disciplinary team of Adam Brennan (Construction Management) from Bundoran, Co Donegal, Ali Al-Windi (Architectural Technology) from William St, Galway city, Declan Coll (Civil Engineering) from Falcarragh, Co Donegal and Liam Flatley (Quantity Surveying) from Belcarra, Castlebar, Co Mayo, beat off stiff competition from ITs and universities’ teams across the country to win the challenge which took place in the Croke Park Conference Centre, Dublin earlier this month (November 2019).
The students’ project was a 1770s Georgian building in poor and unstable condition, needing both internal and external restoration. Adjacent to the Georgian building was a newer office building which was scheduled for demolition; the demolition included a critical ESB sub-station which powered the neighbouring restaurant. The team developed plans to replace the sub-station whilst also creating a temporary advertising façade to ensure the restaurant remained appealing to customers and could stay open during the build. The students also developed plans to allow building quality to be managed and ensure confirmation that all building regulations requirements were met. Compliance with building regulations has become significantly more onerous in recent years, following extensive changes in building control legislation following high profile failures such a Priory Hall. The students also planned how public safety could be maintained, on and around the busy and congested city centre site.
The team also developed detailed logistics and traffic plans for the project including proposals to manage time and cost impacts on the project. Factors such as traffic management involved considering how the Dublin City Council operation “free flow” traffic initiative over the Christmas period would impact the site and also the loss of local parking spaces. Dealing with hazardous legacy materials such as asbestos and lead paint and maintaining both power and drainage for the restaurant were also involved.
Following completion of the written planning, the teams were involved in two rounds of presentations of their plans to a panel of leading expert judges from industry and the professions. The teams were firstly whittled down to a final three who were then further questioned by the judges in a second round of detailed evaluation.
GMIT lecturers and competition mentors John Hanahoe and Dr Martin Taggart paid tribute to the GMIT team, saying: “This is a fantastic achievement by our students. They performed to a very professional standard and really impressed the industry judges. The competition itself is a great opportunity for the students to engage in real life interdisciplinary practice, as well as it being an enjoyable and sociable experience.”
Mary Rogers, Head of the GMIT Department of Building & Civil Engineering, says: “GMIT has been involved in the CIOB student challenge for a number of years now. We are fortunate to have cross-disciplinary undergraduate programmes in Architectural Technology, Civil Engineering, Construction Management and Quantity Surveying where students can contribute their specific expertise and work together to problem solve construction projects as a team. We also have had great support from local construction and consultancy companies over the years who give their time, experience and knowledge to encourage our students to understand the whole construction process and where their discipline fits within that process. This is invaluable learning for our students who relate particularly well to the collaborative environment generated through a multi-disciplinary team setting.”
For further information on programmes in the GMIT Department of Building & Civil Engineering, see:
Galway-Mayo IT, IT Sligo and Letterkenny IT are working towards becoming a Technological University for the west and northwest of Ireland.
Back row, L to R: GMIT student Ali Al-Windi from William St, Galway; John Sweeney, National Chair of CIOB; Adrian Lynch, Mitchell McDermott, competition co-sponsors; Tommy Drumm, MD Collen Construction and former Dublin All-Ireland Captain; GMIT student Declan Coll from Falcarragh, Co Donegal. Front row, L to R: Dr Martin Taggart, GMIT lecturer, GMIT student Liam Flatley from Belcarra, Castlebar, Co Mayo, GMIT student Adam Brennan from Bundoran, Co Donegal, and John Hanahoe, GMIT Lecturer.